|
|
||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 Department of Physiology and Neuroscience, New York University Medical School, 550 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
(Received 29 June 2004;
accepted after revision 20 December 2004;
first published online 21 December 2004)
Corresponding author P. A. Rhodes: Department of Physiology and Neuroscience, NYU Medical School, 550 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA. Email: paul{at}rhodesholdings.net
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The electrophysiological properties of relay cells from a somatic intracellular perspective demonstrated rebound postanodal exaltation (Anderson et al. 1964) following release from a hyperpolarization. The calcium dependent spike properties responsible for this rebound response and their role in neuronal oscillation was descovered later on in thalamic slices (Llinás & Jahnsen, 1982; Jahnsen and Llinás 1984a,b) and were also observed in vivo (Deschènes et al. 1982). In fact, the production of a low threshold T-current-driven burst upon release from hyperpolarized potential and the production of a train of single spikes following stimulation from depolarized potentials is now well established. The aforementioned two modes of intrinsic response can be readily modelled using a single somatic compartment with an appropriate set of voltage and calcium concentration-gated currents (Huguenard & McCormick, 1992; McCormick & Huguenard, 1992), or with a small set of coupled differential equations (Rose & Hindmarsh, 1985). However, both ascending and descending inputs to thalamic relay cells arrive on the dendritic tree, and so the study of synaptic integration in model cells requires simulations incorporating the electrically active properties of the dendritic tree. A first step in this regard was achieved by Crunelli (Antal et al. 1996) and Destexhe, Huguenard and coworkers (Destexhe et al. 1998) with relay cell models including a dendritic tree which incorporated dendritic T-current densities. In the latter work, a comparison of T-current densities in recordings from acutely dissociated and intact cells led to the inference that a higher density of T-current exists in the dendrites than in the soma. The high distal T-current density featured in this model has in turn been the foundation for a number of recent conjectures about relay cell responses to synaptic inputs upon the distal dendrites (Zhan et al. 2000).
There is, however, another less well explored intrinsic electrophysiological characteristic of relay cells for which models have not yet accounted: at somatic potentials near spike threshold, relay cells produce a waxing and waning rapid high threshold oscillation observable at the soma (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997). Optical [Ca2+] imaging and pharmacological tests indicate that this oscillation correlates with a high threshold current in the dendrites, the properties of which have not been characterized. These findings relate to earlier pharmacological and electrophysiological evidence implying the presence of a dendritic high threshold inactivating Ca2+ current, as revealed by high threshold spikes occurring in the presence of the A-type K+ channel blocker 4-aminopyramidine (4-AP; Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984b).
Here we present the development of a new model of the thalamic relay cell. Its construction has been guided by the simultaneous constraints that it must produce the familiar regular spiking relay mode and low threshold rebound bursts which characterize these cells, as well as the less-studied oscillation occurring at near-threshold somatic potentials. We arrive at a model cell which is capable of the production of isolated high threshold Ca2+ spikes in distal branch segments, driven by a rapidly inactivating intermediate threshold channel. Further, the model produces the low threshold spike behaviour of the relay cell without requiring high T-current density in the distal dendritic segments. Thus, it presents an alternative picture of the dendritic tree of relay cells, in which fast high threshold Ca2+ events occur in distal dendritic branches, while slower low threshold spikes are primarily driven by T-current located in the somatic and proximal dendritic membrane. Some of these results have been previously presented in abstract form (Rhodes & Llinás, 2003).
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Initial simulations were performed using a simplified dendritic morphology, so that the main elements of the model could be explored more rapidly than is possible with a fully delineated compartment model dendritic tree. Using a study of relay cells of the cat lateral geniculate nucleus (Bloomfield & Sherman, 1987), a simplified compartment model relay cell was constructed, with eight branches and 56 compartments (Fig. 1). Final simulations were performed on a relay cell reconstructed using the NeuroLucida digital system used by Alain Destexhe and John Huguenard (cf. Destexhe et al. 1998) and generously made available to the public. For details of the compartment structure see the website of Alain Destexhe (http://cns.iaf.cnrs-gif.fr/main.html). The reconstructed model cell included 11 branches. To create a compartment model, individual compartments were delineated by branch points, subject to the constraint that no compartment could be longer than 100 µm, i.e. segments > 100 µm in length were subdivided into two segments. To improve the realism of the somatic firing mechanism, a seven-segment axon was appended to the soma (each segment 50 µm in length and 1 µm in diameter). The model neurone thus defined comprised 219 individual segments, with dendritic membrane area 39 000 µm2. All figures provided in the Results below were produced with this more detailed compartment model cell.
|
For relay cells, the passive compartment modelling parameters of membrane resistance (Rm), membrane capacitance (Cm), and cytoplasmic resistivity (Ri) have to be indirectly inferred from the response to small current injections at the soma, since dual patch measurements of soma and distal dendrites required for direct attenuation measurements have not been reported. We specified Rm
= 50 000
cm2, Ri
= 150
cm, Cm
= 1 µF cm2 and a leak driving force reversing at 64 mV, passive parameters similar to those used by Destexhe et al. (1998; Rm
= 27 000
cm2, Ri
= 173
cm, Cm
= 0.9 µF cm2 and leak battery 69.85 mV), and typical of those ascertained for cortical pyramidal cells (Trevelyan & Jack, 2002). The resulting somatic input resistance was 19 M
, with this measurement made following introduction of somatic and dendritic ion channel conductance densities in the completed model, as detailed below. This falls within but towards the lower end of the range of input resistances obtained from a broad sample of relay cells in vitro (Table 1 in Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984a), and suggests that the reconstruction provided by Destexhe and Huguenard was of a fairly large cell (http://www.cnl.salk.edu/~alain/). The somatic input time constant,
in, measured during relaxation to resting voltage following a small depolarizing step, was approximately 19 ms, and resting membrane potential was about 70.5 mV.
|
in, are shaped by membrane current in addition to passive membrane properties. To examine this effect, we switched off the currents active near rest. In these conditions, resting membrane potential increased from 69.5 to 60.5 mV, and Rin and
in increased approximately 5-fold, to 105 M
and 120 ms, respectively. A small (up to ± 0.35 nA) DC bias current was required to establish voltage equilibrium at the soma. The non-uniform current density distributions between soma and dendrites of currents active near rest resulted in a small (several millivolts) standing gradient of voltage at rest between the soma and distal dendrites.
Somatic action potentials and firing threshold
When compared to cortical pyramidal cells, the AP threshold in relay cells occurs at a more positive membrane voltage, just above 40 mV (e.g. Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984a) versus 53 mV in cortical cells (cf. McCormick et al. 1985). To ensure that the model relay cell reflected the high threshold for AP initiation measured in vitro, the voltage dependence of activation and inactivation of the Na+ channel model (see below) was shifted 15 mV to the right along the voltage axis. The delayed rectifier, KDR, was shifted about 11 mV to the right. With these adjustments, the model relay cell action potential threshold was 38 mV (see Fig. 3) upon current step application from 60 mV holding potential, similar to that noted in vitro. This rightward shift in Na+ and KDR voltage gating was also necessary because the presence of suboscillation at somatic potentials of 48 to 45 mV of course establishes that there must be a subthreshold regime above 50 mV. The hypothesized shift of gating to the right with respect to the currents reported in voltage clamp (e.g. Huguenard & McCormick, 1992) may suggest that some aspect of the voltage clamp measurement process causes a leftward shift of activation, as can occur for example with alteration of the phosphorylationdephosphorylation state of the Na+ channel (Catteral, 2000). We introduced densities of Na+ and KDR conductance in the soma, axon and segments abutting the soma so that the AP shape parameters noted in vitro were approximated by the simulated cell. The precise allocation of Na+ channels driving the somatic AP as between soma and axon hillock was not material to the results.
|
All models of relay cells heretofore reported (e.g. McCormick & Huguenard, 1992; Antal et al. 1996; Destexhe et al. 1998) have incorporated a low threshold inactivating Ca2+ conductance, the T-current (CaT), which drives the low threshold spike characteristic of this cell type (Anderson et al. 1964; Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984a,b; Deschènes et al. 1982). The kinetics of CaT we used were taken from that described by Huguenard & McCormick (1992). We found it necessary to shift activation by 5 mV to the right along the voltage axis to prevent excessive CaT active at rest. Without that shift, a hyperpolarizing step from 60 mV showed an unphysiological deflection in the voltage response due to inactivation of the CaT current present at rest (unpublished observations). Because the differing phosphorylation states of channels arising in different experimental preparations can result in 515 mV shifts of channel gating along the voltage axis, when using current kinetics from a collection of experimental studies it is plausible to shift model current voltage dependencies by 510 mV relative to one another to achieve the interaction between currents observed in current clamp mode.
In a prior model of relay cells, Destexhe et al. (1998) argued for a primarily distal distribution of CaT current, in part because of their observation that in dissociated (versus intact) cells CaT current density per unit membrane area was low. However, more recently Destexhe & Sejnowski (2003) have noted that relay cell models with proximal dendritic T-current distribution produce low threshold spikes, consistent with the findings of Zhou et al. (1997) and of Williams & Stuart (2000). These groups patched relay cell dendrites to about 50 µm from the soma. Williams & Stuart (2000) found CaT conductance density rising approximately 2-fold from the soma to the proximal stems and then rapidly falling off by 40 µm from the soma. To take into account experimental measurements of dendritic and somatic T-current density, our model incorporates a conductance density of 2 mS cm2 in the soma, rising to 8 mS cm2 in the proximal branches and falling off to 1 mS cm2 in the distal branches. Thus the present model has a mainly proximal dendritic CaT distribution. The production of rebound bursts demonstrate that with proximal dendritic CaT channels low threshold spikes and rebound bursts are readily produced.
A rapidly inactivating intermediate threshold Ca2+ channel in distal dendrites
Prior relay cell simulations have not incorporated dendritic high threshold Ca2+ current, though electrophyiological evidence indicates that such a current is present (Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984b, pp. 237239) and that a high threshold current underlies the rapid oscillation (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997). Though this current has not yet been isolated and characterized kinetically, the emergence of oscillations at somatic voltages above 48 mV but below spike threshold suggests it activates at somewhat more hyperpolarized levels than a conventional high threshold (L- or N-type) current, hence it may be termed an intermediate threshold Ca2+ current.
An intermediate threshold current with rapid inactivation and voltage threshold somewhat more hyperpolarized than typical high threshold currents has been reported by Magistretti et al. (2000) in entorhinal cells. To enable activation beginning around 48 mV, we shifted the V2 (voltage at which the value of the activation variable is 0.5) of activation of the current of Magistretti et al. (2000) slightly to the left, to 33 mV. The current found by Magistretti et al. (2000) has an inactivation time constant of 20 ms at room temperature, consistent with an inactivation time constant of approximately 7 ms at body temperature (at Q10 = 2.5), which is well suited to produce repetitive events with the peak-to-peak time of 20 ms characteristic of the oscillations (see Fig. 6). We adopted the Magistretti current, as modified, as a candidate current to underlie the rapid oscillations seen in relay cells.
|
Ih, IC, IAHP and KA
It has been established through both electrophysiological and pharmacological manipulations that relay cells incorporate a fast transient K+ current (IA; Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984b), a fast Ca2+-gated K+ current, the C-current (KCa), and a hyperpolarization-gated current composed of a mixture of K+, Na+ and Ca2+ ions, Ih (McCormick & Pape, 1990). Kinetics for IA and Ih were taken from the study of Huguenard & McCormick (1992), and for KCa from Traub et al. (1991), and are summarized in Table 1 and plotted in Fig. 2. Because the effect of Ba2+ on the repolarization of the LTS suggests the presence of a slower Ca2+-gated current (Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984b), ImAHP, was included, though its role and distribution was not material here. We considered the addition of a slower inactivating current, the K2 current discussed by Huguenard & McCormick (1992), but found it was not necessary to obtain the present results, so it was not included.
|
Because of the incorporation of Ca2+-gated K+ channels, KCa, it was necessary to explicitly model the Ca2+ concentration relevant to channel gating. For purposes of this model we chose to gate the currents with [Ca2+]. Two buffers were utilized, one fast and one slow, the kinetics of which are provided in Table 1. In addition, free Ca2+ was ejected from the cytoplasm by membrane pumps of fixed density per unit membrane area.
Kinetic formulae for the ion channels used in this study are provided in Table 1, with the equilibrium values of inactivation and activation depicted graphically to enable comparison with experimentally measured values in Fig. 2. The final ion channel conductance distribution for the model cell is provided in Table 2.
|
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The model neurone ultimately sought had to satisfy all these constraints simultaneously. Conductance density distributions were iteratively varied and the fit between the model and in vitro records, across all these paradigms, was rechecked, channel densities readjusted, and the process iteratively repeated. Initially, adjustments to achieve improved performance in one response worsened performance in another, and so simulations imposing different stimuli were done and redone in rotation, making successive adjustments in channel density distributions. In this manner we were incrementally led to a model cell which allowed all the experimental measurements to be reproduced. The performance of the final relay cell model ultimately resulting from this process and its comparison with records obtained from relay cells in vitro will now be presented.
Response to current steps from a range of holding potentials
The fundamental intrinsic characteristics of thalamic relay cells have been defined by the spectrum of responses they produce to current steps initiated from differing holding voltages (Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984a). Thus, from hyperpolarized holding potentials (80 mV) depolarizing input triggers a burst, whereas from depolarized levels input drives a train of non-accomodating single spikes. Both these defining modes of relay cell response can be produced by single compartment simulations (McCormick & Huguenard, 1992). In addition, in vitro there are two intermediate types of responses which also should be reflected in the simulation: (1) from intermediate levels of holding voltage or with small currents applied at depolarized holding potential, a passive or near-passive response can be elicited; and (2) from intermediate holding potentials (70 mV) an input step can cause an initial spike followed by a long pause, 100 ms or more, following which there abruptly commences a train of regular non-accomodating somatic spikes (Fig. 3 top, 2nd trace). This second transitional behaviour has not been reported in prior models.
Figure 3 displays the response of the model relay cell to somatic current steps from a range of levels of holding potential. In four regimes of holding voltage and input current magnitude, the model cell produced an output similar to the typical responses of relay cells in vitro. The burst produced from hyperpolarized holding potential rode on a large triangular depolarizing potential and included one or more somatic spikes, the number emitted depending in part on Na+ channel threshold and T-channel conductance density (results not shown). In the model relay cell the low threshold burst was primarily driven by proximal T-channel current.
Response upon release from a range of hyperpolarizing steps of differing depths and durations
In vitro, the defining characteristic of the burst mode of firing of relay cells is the production of a burst upon release from hyperpolarizing input, the postinhibitory exhaltation (Anderson et al. 1964; Deschènes et al. 1982; Llinás & Jahnsen, 1982). This response property is thought to be central to the interrelationship of the relay cells with the inhibitory input they receive from the overlying reticular nucleus of the thalamus (cf. Steriade et al. 1997). A systematic relationship can be observed in vitro between the depth and duration of hyperpolarizing input and the rebound current generated, implying that correspondence between the magnitude of the rebound current corresponds to the degree of de-inactivation of the T-current (Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984a,b).
The density of somatic and proximal dendritic T-current was adjusted to reflect the observed relationship between the LTS and the duration and depth of the hyperpolarizing step, to maintain correspondence between characteristics of the LTS produced in vitro with that in the simulated relay cell (Fig. 4). With short (20 ms) hyperpolarizing steps in vitro no rebound burst is seen, while intermediate duration steps (40 ms) elicited a rebound current producing a triangular somatic depolarization which does not reach Na+ firing threshold in the soma and consequently elicits no somatic spikes. Longer steps (>50 ms) produce a larger LTS and one or more spikes, followed by a large after-depolarization and often concluded with a slow after-hyperpolarization (AHP), indicating the activation of K+ currents by the LTS. These characteristics of the sensitivity of the LTS to hyperpolarizing step duration seen in vitro were reflected in the responses of the simulated relay cell (Fig. 4A, right).
|
Response from release of hyperpolarization in TTX, Cd2+ and Ni2+
In vitro experiments in the presence of the Na+ channel blocker TTX established that neither the fast transient Na+ current nor a persistent Na+ current (which has not been included in our model) is involved in generation of the low threshold spike. To confirm that the LTS in the simulated relay cell was Na+ current independent, the effect of TTX was mimicked by elimination of Na+ currents throughout the model cell. As observed in vitro (Jahnsen & Llinás, 1984a), the simulated response upon release from hyperpolarization in TTX was a triangular depolarizing envelope of similar size and duration to that of the control LTS (Fig. 5A). This indicates that, as in vitro, in the simulation Na+ currents do not contribute to the envelope of the LTS and, further, that Na+ current is not substantially involved in initiating the depolarization which proceeds upon break from hyperpolarization. Rather, in the simulation, that depolarization was driven by Ih and CaT (McCormick & Pape, 1990) as noted in prior modelling studies (McCormick & Huguenard, 1992).
|
As a final test of the ionic dependencies of the rebound, in addition to the elimination of the high threshold channels the T-channels were shut off as well. The response following substitution of Ca2+ with Co2+ in the external medium in vitro (Fig. 5C, left) was compared to that in the relay cell following elimination of all Ca2+ channels (and consequently of Ca2+-gated K+ channel activity). This established that in the simulation, as in vitro, the burst was primarily driven by T-current.
Comparison of the in vitro traces in Figs 4 and 5 illustrates the experimentally observed variability in the spike count of rebound bursts. In the simulations, rebound burst depolarizing envelope amplitude and so the number of somatic spikes produced was correlated with the density of CaT conductance in the soma and periosomatic dendrites (Fig. 5). We hypothesize that the number of spikes per burst can be controlled in part by the density of available CaT conductance in and around the cell body, and note that the modulation of that parameter may provide a means of dynamically regulating the number of spikes produced in a rebound burst, and so its impact on synaptic targets.
Ih was included in this model cell with a modest (0.02 mS cm2) uniform distribution, and produced a noticeable sag from the deeper levels of hyperpolarizing steps. However, its elimination did not greatly diminish the LTS. We did not examine the effects of Ih in shaping and enhancing the LTS in detail, nor did we study the consequences of modulation of Ih (and membrane leak) or of somatic versus dendritic loci of Ih current density.
Production of a gamma oscillation in somatic voltage at depolarized somatic potentials
When somatic voltage nears action potential threshold in vitro, the somatic voltage becomes progressively unstable, beginning to oscillate in a ragged fashion at a fast rate (4050 Hz; Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997). As voltage is incremented further, these gamma oscillations, as they may be termed, may become larger in amplitude and more regular in period. The waveform can appear to wax and wane, becoming more regular and larger, then collapsing into ragged small amplitude disturbance, and thereafter regathering coherence and amplitude (Fig. 6A). This phenomenon (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997), which has recently been observed in other components of the thalamocortical loop (cf. Discussion), has not been displayed by existing models of thalamic relay cells, and producing a model cell which accounted for it (along with the familiar relay and LTS behaviour) motivated this work.
The solution we found was the introduction of a quickly inactivating intermediate threshold Ca2+ conductance in the tertiary segments of some (1530%) of the dendritic branches referred to below as hot branches. To enable it to arise near but below action potential threshold, it activated just above 48 mV, below threshold for the Na+ channel in the model cell but well above the range where CaT was completely inactivated. To facilitate production of brief dendritic Ca2+ spikes consistent with the fast period of the somatic oscillation, a fast inactivation process was included. While novel to relay cells, a Ca2+ current with these characteristics has been reported in entorhinal pyramids (Magistretti et al. 2000); whether it exists in some distal branches of relay cells, as proposed here, remains to be confirmed.
The mechanism underlying the gamma oscillation worked as follows: as depolarization in the soma reached approximately 48 mV, dendritic depolarization reached activation threshold for the intermediate threshold Ca2+ current. This influx caused some of the hot distal segments to commence production of a train of regenerative Ca2+ spikes, starting with the end segments with the highest Ca2+ channel density and local input impedance. These regenerative spikes illuminated the entire segment in which they initiated, spread into a sister segment, but often remained isolated in the distal branch (Llinás, 1975; Rhodes, 1999). The dendritic spikes were fast for Ca2+-driven events, as a result of the rapidly inactivating characteristics of the current employed. A high density of KCa and KDR incorporated into the hot segments further sped the repolarization of these isolated spikes. Their brief width and fast repolarization allowed a peak-to-peak time of 1530 ms (cf. Fig. 6).
Each such dendritic branch spike caused a small depolarization of somatic voltage some 12 mV in amplitude. The varying diameters and lengths of these segments, and their correspondingly differing input resistances, caused different segments to have differing threshold and to fire at different times, so that initially the summation was haphazard, and a ragged and small resulting perturbation could be observed at the soma (Fig. 7). As somatic voltage was increased a few millivolts above initial threshold for these distal spikes, more segments reached their threshold and begin to fire, and the magnitude and regularity of the resultant somatic oscillation could increase. The period of these distal isolated dendritic spikes controlled the rate of the somatic oscillation.
|
In vitro the somatic oscillation is occasionally observed to wax and wane, going through periods of the order of 100 ms when the amplitude is smaller and its phase irregular, thereafter recovering both amplitude and regularity (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997). The simulated relay cell produced this phenomenon in two ways, as follows. First, the isolated spiking amongst several branches may drift in and out of phase. When out of phase, their composite effect at the soma cancels and so is smaller and ragged, whereas when firing in several distal branches drifts into phase their combined effect at the soma sums, with the amplitude and regularity of the somatic oscillation improving (Fig. 7). In the subthreshold regime this entrainment is not tight, and as the distal branch spikes drift back out of phase the somatic voltage oscillation, and the waxing and waning sometimes characteristic of the oscillation in vitro, ensues. Second, the amplitude of one or more of the distal spikes could itself fade, and later recover (Fig. 8), with a resultant waning and waxing of the amplitude of the somatic oscillation.
|
The effect of TTX, Ni2+ and Cd2+ on the gamma oscillation
The ionic basis underlying the oscillation arising at near-threshold voltages was determined in vitro by application of blockers of Na+ and high threshold channels. We applied these perturbations to the model cell by turning off the respective currents, and confirmed the same ionic dependencies. Thus, when TTX was applied the oscillations were not affected (Fig. 8), demonstrating that they are neither materially facilitated by a window current in somatic Na+ nor produced by transient dendritic Na+ spikes, and that in this cell type gamma oscillation does not involve the persistent Na+ current. Since the oscillation is produced in a depolarized state, T-current is not likely to be involved in its production; in the simulation, shutting off T-channels had no effect upon the oscillation (result not shown). However, when Cd2+ was added to the bath in vitro the ripple was eliminated, indicating that it is produced by a high threshold Ca2+ channel (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997). The elimination of high threshold channel conductance in the simulation completely eliminated the distal dendritic events and the gamma oscillation (Fig. 8), confirming that the same pharmacological sensitivities found in vitro were exhibited by the model cell.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Alternative mechanisms for production of a ragged waxing and waning subthreshold oscillation
Before arriving at the solution described above, we first attempted to identify a solution with uniform dendritic distribution, varying the density of the current and seeking progressive onset of a ragged subthreshold oscillation at high somatic voltage. However, with uniformly distributed intermediate threshold conductance, at any channel conductance density at which a dendritic spike occurred the tree fired as a whole, and when that occurred full somatic spiking, not subthreshold oscillation, followed. When a modest density (2 mS cm2) of L-type high threshold Ca2+ conductance was introduced in the dendrites, the model cell behaviour did not qualitatively change (not shown). Thus, while for parsimony dendritic CaL was omitted in the model, the present results clearly do not exclude its presence.
A solution in which the currents generating the oscillation were primarily in the soma was also sought. By including conventional non-inactivating L-type high threshold current along with an opposing K+ current in the soma, we found it was possible to produce a rapid high threshold oscillation. To prevent full action potentials in the soma, a somatic delayed rectifier was included at a high density, so that the repolarizing current could catch the somatic Ca2+ spike before it fulfilled, enabling a subthreshold oscillation to result. However, whenever the currents driving the oscillation were concentrated in the somatic membrane the oscillation produced was metronomically regular and smooth, never the ragged, waxing and waning phenomenon seen in vitro (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997; their Fig. 3). For this reason, we ruled out a somatically centred current as the primary generator of the oscillation.
A possible classification of alternative mechanisms for subthreshold oscillation
In the model relay cell (as with relay cells in vitro) the frequency of the subthreshold oscillation was not strongly dependent upon somatic voltage. Rather, in the model the oscillation period corresponded to the time course of isolated dendritic branch spikes, which was largely independent of somatic voltage. The time course of the dendritic spikes was instead controlled by the inactivation time constant of the dendritic intermediate threshold Ca2+ channel, along with the activationdeactivation kinetics of the dendritic delayed rectifier and of the fast [Ca2+]-gated K+ current, which together quickly repolarize the dendritic spike. Alteration of these parameters thus could change oscillation frequency. In contrast, in the subthreshold oscillations observed, for example, in prefrontal neurones (Llinás et al. 1991) the frequency of subthreshold oscillations and somatic voltage are correlated with a linear relationship. In exploring alternative mechanisms for the relay cell, we found that when somatic depolarizing current was the primary driver the subthreshold oscillation was both more regular (i.e. not ragged) and that its frequency was correlated with injected current and hence average somatic potential (P. Rhodes and R. Llinás, unpublished results). Though outside the scope of the present work, this observation suggests a possible means of classification whereby the existence or absence of a correlation between somatic potential and oscillation frequency is associated with whether the generation mechanism for subthreshold oscillation is somatic or dendritic, respectively.
Summary and implications of the present model for the integration of distal dendritic synaptic inputs
The present work furnishes a model relay cell which accounts for the gamma oscillation in somatic voltage produced at high subthreshold levels of somatic potential (Pedroarena & Llinás, 1997), while still producing the regular spiking relay mode and low threshold rebound burst behaviour characteristic of previous relay cell models. The model predicts the presence of regenerative events in distal branches driven by a rapidly inactivating intermediate threshold Ca2+ current and, should it prove accurate, will have implications for the integration of spatiotemporal patterns of distal synaptic input. While an examination of the effects of simulated distal and proximal synaptic input on the model relay cell is beyond the scope of the present work, some observations can be noted. First, descending synaptic input from layer VI pyramidal cells impinge upon the distal dendrites of relay cells (cf. Sherman & Guillery, 2001) and therefore the hypothesized regenerative events would play a role in shaping the responsiveness of relay cells to descending cortical input. Conceivably, asynchronous depolarizing drive could inactivate the distal inactivating intermediate threshold Ca2+ current, while rhythmic synchronous arriving EPSPs could readily trigger spikes, particularly if they arrive at a frequency consistent with the cycle time of the distal spikes. This resonance could be further enhanced by an out-of-phase fast IPSP arriving to reinforce the active repolarization of the dendritic spike, thus contributing to a faster and more complete recovery from inactivation of the spike-generating Ca2+ current. We are led to consider the relay cell as having resonance properties which could make it capable of being selectively responsive to coherent descending input to a subset of its distal branches. The implications of this sort of cortico-thalamic high frequency resonance have been hypothesized to include the automatic sharpening and resolution of cortical object representations (Llinás et al. 1990; Sillito et al. 1994) in the face of competing inputs, often described as binding.
Gamma oscillations in other cells in the cortico-thalamic loop
The fast membrane oscillations occurring at high somatic potential are not unique to thalamic relay cells. They appear in a recent report (Bannister et al. 2002) on the intrinsic physiology of neocortical layer IV stellate (cf. their Fig. 3) and layer VI pyramidal cells (Bannister et al. 2002), have been noted in cortical layer IV interneurones (Llinás et al. 1991) and very recently were reported in striatal interneurones (Braci et al. 2003). Thomson et al. (2002) desribe fast (80100 Hz) subthreshold oscillations in parvalbumin-positive interneurones and suggest that they may foster the generation of trains of action potentials at that rate. Pinault (1992) has reported a voltage-dependent 40 Hz oscillation in nucleus reticularis thalami (NRT) cells. Though in interneurones the oscillations thus far appear to be due to Na+ rather than Ca2+ currents, the similarities in somatic voltage traces in these cell types suggests the possibility that in each case the coordination of distal dendritic spikes plays a role. If this phenomenon occurs in layer IV stellate cells and layer IV interneurones, both of which receive relay cell input, along with the layer IV cell which conveys descending input from the cortical column back to the relay cell distal segments, it is inviting to ask whether some emergent coordination results. Might the thalamocorticothalamic and perhaps the corticostriatocortical loops operate as tuners, sensitive to coherent activity at preferred frequencies? Such a resonance may be amplified by, and indeed will depend upon, a matching of time kinetics with other physiological components of the circuit, such as the currents which control the repolarization and recovery following somatic firing. Further, the resonance could be enhanced by frequency selectivity in synaptic efficacy, and indeed a frequency dependence of average EPSP amplitude has been observed in the descending input impinging upon relay distal branches from layer VI (Pedroarena & Llinás, 2001). The hypothesis that the thalamocortical and corticostriatal loops incorporate elements which are suited to frequency resonance invites further study of the input/output characteristics of other key elements of the thalamocortical and corticostriatal circuits, particularly of the presently little-understood layer VI cells which convey the feedback from cortex to the relay cells.
Finally, it remains to address how the individual cellular and synaptic components of the thalamocortical circuit function together when they are assembled into an interacting circuit. We suspect that achievement of a detailed understanding of the thalamocortical loop will require both new experimental methods capable of monitoring many elements of a thalamocortical column in action along with simulations synthesizing physiologically faithful models of the components into an operating circuit which may then be compared side-by-side with such experimental results. The present relay cell model is intended to offer a building block towards that purpose. Needless to say, much experimental work remains before we can conclude the accuracy of the thalamic relay cell model proposed here, or therefore its implications regarding the interaction between relay cell dendritic electro-responsiveness and the patterning of descending input.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Antal K, Emri Z, Tóth TI & Crunelli V (1996). Model of a thalamocortical neurone with dendritic voltage-gated ion channels. Neuroreport 7, 26552658.[Medline]
Bannister NJ, Nelson JC & Jack JJB (2002). Excitatory inputs to spiny cells in layers 4 and 6 of cat striate cortex. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B 357, 17931808.[CrossRef][Medline]
Bloomfield
SA
&
Sherman
SM (1987). Passive cable properties and morphological correlates of neurones in the lateral geniculate nucleus of the cat. J Physiol
383, 653692.
Braci
E, Centonze
D, Giorgio
B
&
Calabresi
P (2003). Voltage-dependent membrane potential oscillations of rat striatal fast-spiking interneurons. J Physiol
549, 121130.
Catterall WA (2000). Structure and regulation of voltage-gated Ca2+ channels. Ann Rev Cell Dev Biol 16, 521555.[CrossRef][Medline]
Deschènes M, Roy JP & Steriade M (1982). Thalamic bursting mechanism: an inward slow current revealed by membrane hyperpolarization. Brain Res 239, 289293.[CrossRef][Medline]
Destexhe
A, Neubig
M, Ulrich
D
&
Huguenard
JR (1998). Dendritic low-threshold calcium currents in thalamic relay cells. J Neurosci
18, 35743588.
Destexhe
A
&
Sejnowski
TJ (2003). Interactions between membrane conductances underlying thalamocortical slow-wave oscillations. Physiol Rev
83, 14011453.
Huguenard
JR, Coulter
DA
&
Prince
DA (1991). A fast transient potassium current in thalamic relay neurons: kinetics of activation and inactivation. J Neurophysiol
66, 13041315.
Huguenard
JR
&
McCormick
DA (1992). Simulation of the currents involved in rhythmic oscillations in thalamic relay neurons. J Neurophysiol
68, 13731383.
Jahnsen
H
&
Llinás
R (1984a). Electrophysiological properties of guinea-pig thalamic neurones: an in vitro study. J Physiol
349, 205226.
Jahnsen
H
&
Llinás
R (1984b). Ionic basis for the electroresponsiveness and oscillatory properties of guinea-pig thalamic neurones in vitro. J Physiol
349, 227247.
Jones EG (1985). The Thalamus. Plenum, New York.
Llinás R (1975). The electro-responsive characteristics of the dendrites of central neurons.
Llinás R (1990). In Fidia Research Foundation Neuroscience Award Lectures, ed. Changeux J-P, Llinás R R, Purves D & Bloom F. pp. 110. Raven Press, New York.
Llinás R & Jahnsen H (1982). Electrophysiology of mammalian thalamic neurones in vitro. Nature 297, 406408.[CrossRef][Medline]
Llinás
RR, Grace
AA
&
Yarom
Y (1991). In vitro neurons in mammalian cortical layer 4 exhibit intrinsic oscillatory activity in the 10- to 50-Hz frequency range. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
88, 897901.
McCormick
DA, Connors
BW, Lighthall
JW
&
Prince
DA (1985). Comparative electrophysiology of pyramidal and sparsely spiny stellate neurons of the neocortex. J Neurophysiol
54, 782806.
McCormick
DA
&
Huguenard
JR (1992). A model of the electrophysiological properties of thalamocortical relay neurons. J Neurophysiol
68, 13841410.
McCormick
DA
&
Pape
HC (1990). Noradrenergic and serotonergic modulation of a hyperpolarization-activated cation current in thalamic relay neurones. J Physiol
431, 319342.
Magistretti J, Brevi S & de Curtis M (2000). A blocker-resistant, fast-decaying, intermediate-threshold calcium current in paleocortical pyramidal neurons. Eur J Neurosci 12, 23762386.[CrossRef][Medline]
Pedroarena
CM
&
Llinás
R (1997). Dendritic calcium conductances generate high-frequency oscillation in thalamocortical neurons. Proc Nat Acad Sci U S A
94, 724728.
Pedroarena CM & Llinás R (2001). Interactions of synaptic and intrinsic electroresponsiveness determine corticothalamic activation dynamics. Thalam Rel Syst 1, 314.
Pinault D & Deschènes M (1992). Voltage-dependent 40-Hz oscillations in rat reticular thalamic neurons in vivo. Neurosci 51, 245258.[CrossRef][Medline]
Rhodes PA (1999). The functional implications of active dendrites in pyramidal cells. In Cerebral Cortex, vol. 13, pp. 139201. Pergamon Press, New York.
Rhodes PA & Llinás R (2003). A new model for thalamic relay cells. Program no. 171.3, 2003 Abstract Viewer/Itinerary Planner. Society for Neuroscience, Washington (online).
Rose RM & Hindmarsh JL (1985). A model of a thalamic neuron. Proc R Soc London B 225, 161193.[Medline]
Sherman M & Guillery R (2001). Exploring the Thalamus. Academic Press, San Diego.
Sillito AM, Jones HE, Gerstein GL & West DC (1994). Feature-linked synchronization of thalamic relay cell firing induced by feedback from the visual cortex. Nature 369, 479482.[CrossRef][Medline]
Steriade M, Jones EG & McCormick DA (1997). Thalamus. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Thomson AM, Bannister AP, Mercer A & Morris OT (2002). Target and temporal pattern selection at neocortical synapses. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B 357, 17811791.[CrossRef][Medline]
Traub
RD, Wong
RK, Miles
R
&
Michelson
H (1991). A model of a CA3 hippocampal pyramidal neuron incorporating voltage-clamp data on intrinsic conductances. J Neurophysiol
66, 635650.
Trevelyan
AJ
&
Jack
JJB (2002). Detailed passive cable models of layer 2/3 pyramidal cells in rat visual cortex at different temperatures. J Physiol
539, 623636.
Williams
SR
&
Stuart
GJ (2000). Action potential backpropagations and the somato-dendritic distribution of ion channels in thalamocortical neurons. J Neurosci
20, 13071317.
Zhan
XJ, Cox
CL
&
Sherman
SM (2000). Denditic depolarization efficiently attenuates low-threshold calcium spikes in thalamic relay cells. J Neurosci
20, 39093914.
Zhou
Q, Godwin
DW, O'Malley
DM
&
Adams
PR (1997). Visualization of calcium influx through channels that shape the burst and tonic firing modes of thalamic relay cells. J Neurophysiol
77, 28162825.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. R. Llinas, S. Choi, F. J. Urbano, and H.-S. Shin {gamma}-Band deficiency and abnormal thalamocortical activity in P/Q-type channel mutant mice PNAS, November 6, 2007; 104(45): 17819 - 17824. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |